Let's dive into a hidden gem from the '70s that's streaming for free and deserves a fresh look. I'm talking about “The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean”, a Western comedy starring Paul Newman, which, despite its critical acclaim back in the day, seems to have faded into obscurity. But why is that? Well, personally, I think it has something to do with the changing cultural landscape and our evolving perceptions of law and order. In today's climate, Bean's self-appointed justice might not sit well with audiences, especially when compared to the more nuanced portrayal of law enforcement in modern media.
This film, directed by the legendary John Huston, offers a unique perspective on the Wild West. It's a star-studded affair, with Newman bringing his charismatic charm to the role of Judge Bean, and a supporting cast that includes Victoria Principal, Ned Beatty, and Anthony Perkins. But what makes this film particularly fascinating is the clash of creative visions between Huston and the screenwriter, John Milius.
Milius, known for his conservative leanings and colorful writing style, had a very specific vision for Bean – one that was seemingly at odds with Huston's interpretation. Milius described his version as a “Beverly Hills Western,” suggesting a more serious and perhaps darker take on the material. He saw Bean as an obsessed, Lawrence of Arabia-like figure, a man driven by a vision of progress and civilization, willing to kill in its name. It's a fascinating character study, and one that Milius believed was watered down by Huston.
From my perspective, the film's aesthetic, which draws heavily from “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid,” might also contribute to its modern-day obscurity. The interlude with Newman and Principal's picnic, accompanied by Andy Williams' “Marmalade, Molasses and Honey,” is a prime example of this dated approach. However, I'd argue that the film's true charm lies in its ensemble cast and their ability to bring these quirky characters to life.
Despite the creative differences, the film's dialogue, crafted by Milius, is a highlight. Newman, Beatty, Perkins, and even Huston himself deliver some memorable lines. And while Milius' version might have been more humorous, I find the melancholy tone of Huston's film, with its Ava Gardner cameo, to be a fitting conclusion.
So, if you're looking for a unique Western experience, “The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean” is definitely worth a watch. It offers a glimpse into a bygone era, a time when Westerns could be both entertaining and thought-provoking. And the best part? You can catch it for free on YouTube. Give it a go and decide for yourself whether this overlooked gem deserves a place in the pantheon of great Westerns.
